What If Our House Is Worth Less Than We Owe on It During a Divorce?
By Tiffany Stock, Real Estate Agent, CA DRE #01466776
Tiffany Stock is a real estate agent in Danville, CA helping sellers (including move-up families, luxury sellers, and those navigating a divorce or probate sale) get their home sold, personally, start to finish. She holds a Certified Negotiation Expert (CNE) and Master Certified Negotiation Expert (MCNE) designation, and a dedicated divorce real estate designation. Call 925-989-2138 or visit www.tiffstock.com.
This article explains general considerations. It is not legal or financial advice. Talk to your attorney and a housing counselor about your specific situation.
Short answer
An underwater home in a divorce generally gets treated as a zero or negative-value asset in the overall property division, rather than something with equity to split. Your real options are: one spouse keeps it and takes on the full underwater mortgage, you sell at a loss (sometimes as a short sale), or in rare cases, walk away and face the consequences of foreclosure. Each has real trade-offs worth understanding before deciding.
Why this situation needs careful handling
An underwater home doesn't just complicate the property division math, it means someone has to actively decide to take on a liability, not receive an asset. That's a fundamentally different negotiation than dividing equity, and it needs to be approached that way.
Step-by-step: understanding your real options
- Confirm the actual numbers. Get a real, current valuation and compare it honestly to what's owed, don't assume based on what the home was worth when you bought it or a rough guess.
- If one spouse wants to keep the home, they generally take on the full underwater mortgage and may need to compensate the other spouse's share of the negative equity through other assets in the settlement, or the negative equity may simply be treated as belonging entirely to whoever keeps the home.
- If selling, understand a short sale may be necessary, selling for less than what's owed, which requires lender approval and has its own process separate from a standard sale.
- Know that California generally protects against deficiency judgments in most short sale situations, meaning you typically won't owe the lender the difference after a properly structured short sale, though this is exactly the kind of detail to confirm with an attorney for your specific loan situation.
- Treat foreclosure as a last resort, not a shortcut. It carries serious credit consequences and potential complications, and should only be considered after exploring other options with a housing counselor and your attorney.
Common mistakes
- Assuming the underwater amount just disappears or gets ignored in the divorce settlement, without addressing who's actually responsible for it.
- Not getting a real, current valuation before making decisions based on outdated assumptions about the home's worth.
- Attempting a short sale without lender approval and proper process, which can create real complications.
- Considering foreclosure without exploring other options first, the consequences are serious and often avoidable with the right guidance.
A typical example
This is a typical example of how this situation plays out, not a specific client's story.
A Danville divorcing couple discovered their home was worth meaningfully less than they owed, following a period of market softness after their purchase. Rather than treating this as a dead end, working through the real options with their attorneys (including exploring whether one spouse could realistically take on the underwater mortgage versus pursuing a short sale) led to a structured short sale that resolved the situation without a deficiency judgment or foreclosure on either spouse's record.
FAQ
Will I owe the bank money after a short sale in California?
Generally no, in most short sale situations California law protects against deficiency judgments, but confirm this applies to your specific loan and situation with your attorney.
Is foreclosure ever the right choice?
It's rarely the best option, given the credit and financial consequences, but every situation is different, a housing counselor and your attorney can help you understand if it's genuinely your best remaining option.
Can we just keep paying the mortgage together after the divorce until it's no longer underwater?
Legally possible, but it keeps both spouses financially entangled indefinitely with an asset neither may want, worth weighing carefully against the alternatives.
Facing an underwater home during your divorce and need an honest read on the real numbers? Call Tiffany Stock at 925-989-2138 or visit www.tiffstock.com.
Related reading: How is home equity actually divided in a California divorce? · Should we sell our house or rent it out during the divorce?
Keller Williams Danville, CA. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Comments
Post a Comment