What Happens If the Buyer's Inspection Finds Something After We're Already in Contract?
By Tiffany Stock, Real Estate Agent, CA DRE #01466776
Tiffany Stock is a real estate agent in Danville, CA helping sellers (including move-up families, luxury sellers, and those navigating a divorce or probate sale) get their home sold, personally, start to finish. Call 925-989-2138 or visit www.tiffstock.com.
Short answer
The buyer typically has a defined inspection contingency period to request repairs, a price reduction, or a credit, and you have real options in response: agree, negotiate a middle ground, or, depending on your contract terms, decline and let the buyer decide whether to move forward, renegotiate, or walk. It's rarely as one-sided as it first feels.
Why this feels worse than it usually is
An inspection report can look alarming, long, technical, every issue flagged regardless of severity. Most inspection reports aren't a reason to panic; they're a starting point for a negotiation, and the vast majority of inspection issues get resolved without the deal falling apart.
Step-by-step: how to actually handle it
- Read the report with your agent, not alone. A good agent can help you separate "genuinely significant" from "standard inspector boilerplate that shows up on every report."
- Understand your contract's specific contingency terms. California purchase agreements generally spell out exactly how many days the buyer has to request repairs and how you're required to respond.
- Decide your real options: fix it, credit it, or hold your position. You're not obligated to agree to everything requested, you can counter with a partial credit, offer to fix only the safety-relevant items, or decline entirely depending on your contract.
- Get a second opinion on anything expensive or ambiguous. A specialist (roofer, electrician, foundation expert) can sometimes clarify that an inspector's flagged concern is smaller than it looked on paper.
- Negotiate like a real conversation, not a standoff. Most buyers who are this far into a transaction want to close, not walk, a fair middle-ground response usually keeps the deal moving.
Common mistakes
- Panicking and agreeing to everything requested, including items that are minor or standard for a home of that age.
- Digging in and refusing everything, which can push a genuinely motivated buyer to walk over something that could have been resolved with a modest credit.
- Missing your response deadline under the contract's contingency timeline, which can have real consequences depending on the terms.
- Not getting a second opinion on a big-ticket item before agreeing to a large credit or repair.
A typical example
This is a typical example of how this situation plays out, not a specific client's story.
A Danville seller received an inspection report flagging a dozen items, several of which looked alarming at first read. Walking through it item by item with an agent who separated the two or three genuinely significant issues from routine inspector notes led to a credit that addressed the real concerns without the seller overpaying for minor items the buyer's agent had bundled into the request.
FAQ
Do I have to fix everything the inspection report flags?
No, you're negotiating, not obligated to agree to every item. Your contract's specific terms govern your options.
What if I don't respond within the contingency period?
This depends on your specific contract terms and can have real consequences, this is exactly the kind of deadline your agent should be tracking closely on your behalf.
Can the buyer walk away entirely over inspection findings?
Generally yes, within their contingency period, if terms aren't resolved to their satisfaction, which is part of why a fair, prompt response usually serves you better than a rigid one.
In the middle of an inspection negotiation and want a clear-eyed read on your options? Call Tiffany Stock at 925-989-2138 or visit www.tiffstock.com.
Related reading: I got multiple offers on my Danville home, how do I pick the right one? · What should I fix before listing my Danville home?
Keller Williams Danville, CA. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Comments
Post a Comment